How TireDoc recommends tires — methodology and limits
How TireDoc recommends tires — methodology and limits
TireDoc does not sell tires. We recommend them.
That only works if you can see how the recommendation is made, where the data comes from, and where it runs out. This page is that explanation. If we change our method, we change this page.
How a recommendation is built
Every recommendation follows the same order. We do not start with a tire. We start with you.
1. Vehicle. Year, make, model, and trim. This sets the original tire size, load index, and speed rating your vehicle was built for. Those come from the manufacturer's specifications for that vehicle, and they are the floor nothing goes below.
2. Use. How the vehicle is actually driven: daily commuting, highway miles, family trips, towing, hauling, light off-road use, or a mix. A tire that suits one use can be a poor choice for another.
3. Climate. Where you drive: how cold it gets, how much snow and rain you really see. This is what decides between all-season, all-weather, and winter tires, as explained in our guide to those three types.
4. Priority. What matters most to you within the safe options: lowest cost over time, longest life, wet grip, winter grip, comfort and quiet, or a balance.
5. Three tires. From the tires that fit your vehicle and match your answers, we present three: a best overall fit, a lower-cost option, and a premium option. Each one shows why it is there, in plain language, and what it gives up compared with the other two. A recommendation with no trade-off named is marketing, not advice.
The data we use
- UTQG grades — treadwear, traction, and temperature — from the public database maintained by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA). We label this data with its limits wherever we show it.
- Manufacturer specifications — sizes offered, load and speed ratings, category, and mileage warranty — from the tire makers' own published information for each model.
- Prices — from the retailers we link to, recorded with the source and the date. Prices change. A price we show is a price we saw, on the date we state, not a promise about today.
Our main comparison metric, cost per 10,000 miles, is price divided by mileage warranty, multiplied by 10,000. Its formula and its limits are published in full in our guide to that metric.
What we do not know
Honesty about a recommendation includes its blind spots. These are ours:
- We do not run our own instrumented tire tests. We are not a test laboratory. Where independent test results exist, they belong to the organizations that ran them, and we say who they are.
- UTQG treadwear is self-certified by manufacturers and is not comparable across brands. We use it only for comparisons within a brand, and we do not build cross-brand claims on it. See our UTQG guide.
- A mileage warranty is a manufacturer's commitment, not an independent measurement. Real tread life depends on your vehicle, alignment, pressure, rotation, roads, and driving.
- We do not hold inventory and we do not see live stock at every retailer. A tire we recommend may be out of stock in your size at a given shop on a given day.
- Fitment data can contain errors, including ours. That is why the check below is not optional.
Safety rules we never break
- We never recommend a tire with a lower load index or speed rating than your vehicle's original equipment.
- We never recommend a size that changes the overall diameter beyond the accepted tolerance for your vehicle, without naming it as a change and explaining it.
- Always confirm your size against the placard on your driver's door frame before you buy. If our data and your placard disagree, your placard wins. Tell us, and we will fix our data.
How we make money
Some links on TireDoc are affiliate links. If you click one and buy from that retailer, we may earn a commission from the retailer. It does not change the price you pay.
Three rules govern this, without exception:
- No paid placements. No manufacturer or retailer can pay to be recommended, to be ranked higher, or to have a competitor removed.
- The same three-tire method applies to every vehicle, whether or not the resulting tires have affiliate programs attached.
- Affiliate relationships are disclosed on our affiliate disclosure page and where links appear.
If a recommendation ever conflicts with a commission, the recommendation wins and the commission is the thing that goes. That is the whole business model: trust first, because without it there is no second visit.
Corrections
If you find an error — a wrong size, a wrong warranty figure, an outdated price presented as current — contact us at the contact form on this site. We correct confirmed errors and note significant corrections on the page that carried them.